The sustainability of culturally competent care was felt to be negatively affected by systemic factors, such as inflexibility among mainstream services and certain health and immigration policies. We speculate that what may have also facilitated psychiatrists adopting this authoritative style was that they tended to consult with patients further along their mental health care pathway, usually after the patient had accepted the need to seek professional help for their distress. All participants recognised that building rapport and a good therapeutic relationship with their patients was critical to delivering culturally competent care. For example, a review of 30 community mental health centres in the US found significant variation across the centres about their understanding of what culturally competent care comprised, but only low to moderate concordance with professional definitions and standards . Although these culturally diverse populations have distinct mental health needs – partially because of the social, political, and historical factors shaping their migration trajectories – what is consistent among these groups is an under-utilization of existing mental health services relative to the local populations 2,3,4,5,6.
Others have warned that changes in clinician knowledge, attitudes, and skills may not actually change clinician behaviors if the institutional structure of health care delivery is also not changed (Kirmayer 2012). Our participants equated time constraints to decreased quality, noting that patients did not receive quality care when treated like hundreds of others. The use of quality assurance and utilization management procedures throughout medicine since the 1990s has linked good clinical treatment to long-term cost controls as person-centered care has transitioned to population-based algorithms (Donald 2001). All groups also mentioned that clinicians should explain more options to patients, but only patients and some clinicians prioritized respecting patient wishes. Future work could examine perceptions of cultural competence across different types of clinicians, at various stages of practice, and in a variety of institutions such as academic, community, and for-profit hospitals. This understanding is consistent with the patient-centered movement across the health disciplines since the 1980s that has prioritized respect for patient wishes in clinical interactions (Saha et al. 2008).
Social science research in health care settings can illuminate our understanding of how people construct institutional culture by comparing what people say with what they think they do (Lambert and McKevitt 2012). This cultural understanding stigmatizes mental illness and may lead to treatment non-adherence (Vargas et al. 2015). One solution may be to ask patients how they wish to be treated during times of acute illness such that patient preferences and the range of clinician responses are discussed in advance of clinical emergencies. Limits on the consultation model appear during acute illness when clinicians may need to treat patients against their preferences (Aggarwal 2012).
DataAnnotation
Consequently, it was suggested that clinical procedures and policies should reflect these. This definition was focussed on an outcome, and included attention to obvious language Psychiatric Services research article differences in the consultation, as well as how culture influences attitudes, expressions of distress, and help seeking practices. Not included were cultural groups defined by physical disabilities, sexual orientation, or other characteristics, as their particular concerns were not in the purview of this project. We included all papers published in English language that were about adults with mental illness.
- Participants also described the rich life experiences of growing up in diverse communities that provided ample opportunities to develop CC.
- A culturally competent mental health provider can take these factors into consideration as they develop treatment plans for their patients.
- Therefore, it is of paramount importance to understand how to effectively and efficiently promote provider cultural competence.
- Patient challenges included cultural understandings of mental health services whereby only “crazy” people presented clinicians and needed psychotherapy.
- Emphasis was given to a genuine willingness and desire to learn about other cultures, rather than this simply being a managerial requirement.
CAMHS Clinical Lead – Psychologist/Family Therapist/Psychotherapist
Addressing refugee and migrant health requires comprehensive approaches. Outpatient and residential therapy tailored to adults navigating depression, anxiety, trauma, and other challenges. Providing youth with tools to manage emotions, strengthen family relationships, and build healthy habits for success. Treatment and support services With this grant, CCHP is scaling up our screening of adolescents and young adults for behavioral health and substance use concerns during routine wellness visits. In honor of Mental Health Awareness Month, Fidelis Care awarded $149,000 in behavioral health grants to nine organizations across New York State, including CCHP.
MST Therapist (Multisystemic Therapy)
The findings highlight the relevance of infusion of CC through theoretical frameworks, clinical practice experiences with diverse clients, as well as life experiences in facilitating the development of CC, while underscoring that trainees need to continue to devote time and efforts toward life-long learning. Future research with larger samples of faculty, students, and practitioners that assesses training in CC, competencies gained, and the extent to which individuals incorporate CC training into their clinical practice is needed. Similarly, for practitioners, both those who did not receive formal training in CC as well as those who did, continuing education in CC needs to be considered mandatory as it is integral to providing ethical care to diverse clients. Graduate training programs should consider opportunities for continued professional development for faculty with respect to CC, for example, through faculty development programs that involve cultural immersion experiences, experiential learning, and self-reflective activities. Faculty participants in both countries reported learning CC primarily through research and clinical experiences, suggesting that many faculty members may not have had exposure to theoretical foundations of CC through coursework in their own training programs. Recommendations As the US becomes increasingly diverse, training programs are responding to the call to become diverse with more faculty and students who are persons of color, members of LGBQ+ community, and/or gender non-binary individuals.
Further, exploring CC training in diverse countries can give us insights into how training in CC may be conceptualized and implemented, highlighting the cultural salience of CC training itself with implications for strengthening such training around the world. No published studies have examined whether and how CC is taught in mental health training programs in the Global South (i.e., Africa, Asia, Latin America). Participants in India described a practical emphasis to their CC training (e.g., learning about CC through life experiences and clinical practice experiences) more so than through coursework, whereas participants in USA described varying levels of coursework related to CC along with practice. Focusing on India and USA, two diverse countries that provide complementary contexts to examine CC, we explored graduate students’, practicing clinicians’, and faculty members’ perspectives regarding CC training they received/provided and future training needs using mixed-methods. Research on CC in mental health training from different world populations is needed due to the context-dependent nature of CC. Mental Health Management Group offers compassionate and competent care for a wide range of mental health, emotional and behavioral conditions.
Skip to content